A single week of trades is mostly noise. A month is the first window that starts to show whether your edge is real, whether your rules are holding and where your money is leaking. A monthly trading review turns a pile of trades into decisions about what to keep, fix or drop.
What Is a Monthly Trading Review?
A monthly trading review is a structured look at all of your trades from the past month. Where the weekly trading review focuses on execution and recent mistakes, the monthly review zooms out to performance, setups, risk and your plan itself.
Weekly vs. Monthly Review
| Weekly review | Monthly review | |
|---|---|---|
| Main question | Did I follow my rules? | Is my edge working? |
| Focus | Execution and emotions | Metrics, setups and risk |
| Output | One or two habit fixes | Plan changes and next-month goals |
| Time needed | 30 to 45 minutes | 60 to 90 minutes |
Step 1: Check the Core Numbers
Start with a handful of metrics and compare them to the previous month and to your long-term average:
- Net P&L after commissions and fees
- Win rate and payoff ratio
- Expectancy per trade, ideally in R
- Profit factor
- Max drawdown for the month
- Number of trades, to spot overtrading
A profitable month does not prove a good process, and a losing month does not prove a bad one. Judge the month by expectancy and rule adherence, not just the final P&L.
Step 2: Break Results Down by Setup
Group your trades by setup, market, time of day and day of week. Most traders find that one or two setups produce nearly all of their profit while another quietly loses money. Use consistent journal tags so this takes minutes instead of hours.
| Setup | Trades | Expectancy (R) | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opening range breakout | 18 | +0.45 | Keep and focus |
| Mid-day reversal | 12 | -0.30 | Pause or redefine |
| Trend pullback | 9 | +0.20 | Keep, gather more data |
Step 3: Audit Your Rule Adherence
Count how many trades followed your trading plan completely. Then compare the results of rule-following trades with rule-breaking ones. This single comparison is often the most persuasive evidence a trader will ever see for sticking to the plan.
- How many trades broke a rule, and which rule most often?
- Did you hit your daily loss limit and respect it?
- Were stops moved, or were trades averaged down?
- Did any trade exceed your planned risk per trade?
Step 4: Review Psychology and Habits
Look at your emotion tags and notes. Which feelings showed up before your worst trades: FOMO, frustration, boredom? Note any revenge trading or losing streak behavior, and whether your preparation routine slipped.
Step 5: Pick Your Best and Worst Trades
Choose your three best and three worst trades by process, not by profit. A good trade follows the plan even if it loses; a bad trade breaks it even if it wins. This guards against outcome bias. For the losers, use the method in how to review losing trades.
Step 6: Set Next Month's Actions
- 1Choose one thing to stop (for example, trading the mid-day reversal).
- 2Choose one thing to improve (for example, honoring stops every time).
- 3Choose one thing to keep doing because it works.
- 4Write one measurable goal, such as 95% rule adherence. See setting trading goals.
- 5Update your plan only if the data supports it, not because of one bad month.
Monthly Trading Review Checklist
- Export or open all trades for the month
- Record net P&L, win rate, expectancy, profit factor and drawdown
- Compare to last month and your average
- Break results down by setup, market and time
- Count rule violations and compare their results
- Review emotion tags and habit slips
- Select best and worst trades by process
- Write three actions and one goal for next month
60-90 min
Time for a monthly review
30+
Trades for more reliable stats
3
Actions to carry into next month
You cannot manage what you do not measure, and you cannot improve what you never review.
TradeEdge calculates your monthly metrics, setup breakdowns and rule adherence automatically, so your review takes minutes of thinking instead of hours of spreadsheet work.