Most traders who quit journaling do not quit because it is hard. They quit because they do not know what to write. "Bought at 4510, sold at 4518, good trade" tells you nothing you could not read off the P&L. The right trading journal prompts force you to record the reasoning, emotion and process that the numbers hide.
Why Prompts Beat Free-Form Notes
Free-form notes drift toward storytelling and excuses. Fixed prompts do the opposite: they make every entry comparable, so after 50 trades you can filter, count and spot patterns. That is the difference between a diary and a trading journal that improves performance.
Keep it short. Answer 5 to 8 prompts per trade in a sentence each. A journal you finish beats a perfect one you abandon.
Before the Trade: 7 Planning Prompts
- 1Which setup from my trading plan is this?
- 2What is the market context (trend, range, news, session)?
- 3Why is this a high-probability trade right now, in one sentence?
- 4Where is my entry, stop and target, and what is the risk/reward ratio?
- 5How much am I risking, and does it respect my 1% rule?
- 6What would invalidate this idea?
- 7On a scale of 1 to 10, how calm and focused am I?
During the Trade: 6 Management Prompts
- 1Did I follow my exit plan or change it mid-trade?
- 2Did I move my stop, and if so why? (See moving stops to break-even.)
- 3Did I add to or scale out of the position by plan or by feeling?
- 4What emotion was strongest while the trade was open (fear, greed, boredom, hope)?
- 5Did I check the chart or P&L compulsively?
- 6How far did the trade go against me and in my favor? (Track MAE and MFE.)
After the Trade: 7 Review Prompts
- 1Did I follow my plan from entry to exit, yes or no?
- 2What was the actual result in R-multiples, not just dollars? (See R-multiple explained.)
- 3If this was a loss, was it bad luck or bad process? Use our guide to reviewing losing trades.
- 4If this was a win, was it skill or luck? Beware of outcome bias.
- 5What is one thing I did well?
- 6What is one thing I would change next time?
- 7How would I grade this trade for execution, from A to F? See the trade grading system.
Emotional Check-In: 5 Psychology Prompts
- Was I trading to make money or to feel something (recover a loss, prove a point, escape boredom)?
- Did I feel FOMO or the urge to revenge trade?
- Would I take this exact trade again if I had just won three in a row? What if I had just lost three?
- What was my physical state (sleep, stress, caffeine, distractions)?
- What would I tell a friend who made this same trade?
Turn Answers into Tags and Metrics
Prompts only pay off when you can query them. Convert the answers into structured fields: setup name, followed plan (yes/no), emotion, grade and mistake type. Then use trading journal tags to filter. For example, compare average R on "followed plan" trades versus "broke plan" trades.
| Prompt answer | What to measure | What it reveals |
|---|---|---|
| Followed plan? Yes/No | Avg R by group | Cost of rule-breaking |
| Strongest emotion | Win rate by emotion | Which feelings hurt your results |
| Setup name | Expectancy per setup | Which setups deserve more size |
| Grade A-F | Avg R by grade | Whether execution drives outcomes |
| Calm score 1-10 | Avg R by score | Your minimum readiness to trade |
A Simple 2-Minute Routine
- 1Before entry: answer prompts 1 to 4 and 7 from the planning list (about 60 seconds).
- 2Right after exit: log result, followed-plan yes/no and a grade (30 seconds).
- 3End of day: add one emotional note and one lesson per session in your end-of-day routine.
- 4Weekly: scan the answers during your weekly review for repeated phrases. Repeats are your patterns.
5-8
Prompts per trade is enough
2 min
Time budget per journal entry
50+
Trades before patterns become reliable
The quality of your questions decides the quality of your edge.
TradeEdge lets you attach setups, emotions, grades and mistake tags to every trade, then shows which answers cost you the most R, so your prompts become analytics instead of homework.