A good Calmar ratio in trading is 1.0 or higher. A ratio between 0.5 and 1.0 is acceptable, 3.0 or more is excellent, and anything below 0.5 means your drawdowns are large relative to what you earn. The Calmar ratio compares your annual return with your worst peak-to-trough loss, so it answers one blunt question: how much pain did you take for each unit of gain?
What the Calmar Ratio Measures
The Calmar ratio divides your annualized return by your maximum drawdown. Because it uses the single worst decline instead of average volatility, it reflects what traders actually feel and what prop firms actually enforce. For the full derivation, read our guide to the Calmar ratio.
Calmar = annualized return / maximum drawdown (both as positive percentages). A 30% annual return with a 15% max drawdown gives a Calmar ratio of 2.0.
Calmar Ratio Benchmarks
| Calmar ratio | Rating | What it usually means |
|---|---|---|
| Below 0 | Losing | The account lost money over the period. Review before risking more. |
| 0 to 0.5 | Weak | Drawdowns are large compared with the gains. Hard to stay with. |
| 0.5 to 1.0 | Acceptable | Returns roughly match the worst loss. Room to improve. |
| 1.0 to 3.0 | Good | Solid return for the drawdown taken. A realistic target for disciplined traders. |
| Above 3.0 | Excellent | Rare. Confirm it with a long sample and real costs before trusting it. |
A Worked Example
Say you start the year with a $50,000 account and finish at $62,500. That is a 25% annual return. During the year your equity peaked at $58,000 and later fell to $49,300 before recovering. The maximum drawdown is (58,000 - 49,300) / 58,000, or 15%.
Your Calmar ratio is 25% / 15%, or about 1.67. That is a good result: you earned roughly one and two-thirds times your worst decline. If the same return had come with a 40% drawdown, the ratio would be 0.63, and most traders would struggle to survive that path.
Calmar vs Sharpe vs Sortino
Sharpe and Sortino measure how bumpy returns are on average. Calmar measures the worst case. A strategy can have a decent Sharpe ratio and still produce one brutal drawdown, which Calmar exposes immediately. Compare it with the good Sharpe ratio benchmarks and the good Sortino ratio benchmarks.
| Metric | Risk measure used | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Sharpe ratio | Standard deviation of all returns | Smooth, symmetric strategies |
| Sortino ratio | Downside deviation only | Strategies with positive skew |
| Calmar ratio | Maximum drawdown | Judging worst-case pain and prop firm limits |
Why Time Frame and Sample Size Matter
The classic Calmar ratio uses a 36-month window. Over a short period, max drawdown has not had time to show itself, so a three-month Calmar can look wonderful right before a bad stretch. Use at least 12 months where possible, and keep the window the same when you compare periods. Our guide on how many trades you need for statistical significance explains why small samples mislead.
1.0+
Good Calmar ratio
3.0+
Excellent Calmar ratio
12+
Months of data before trusting it
How to Improve Your Calmar Ratio
- 1Cut the drawdown, not just the return. Size down after losses and set a daily loss limit so one bad day cannot define your max drawdown.
- 2Limit risk per trade. The one percent rule keeps a losing streak from compounding into a deep hole.
- 3Control combined exposure. Track portfolio heat and avoid correlated positions that lose together.
- 4Remove rule-breaking trades. Tag them in your journal and compare their results with your planned trades.
- 5Know your recovery math. A 20% drawdown needs a 25% gain to break even, as shown in our drawdown recovery guide.
Returns get the attention, but the drawdown decides whether you are still trading long enough to collect them.
TradeEdge tracks your maximum drawdown, equity curve, Sharpe, Sortino and expectancy automatically from your imported trades, so you can monitor the numbers behind your Calmar ratio without a spreadsheet. Read more on what a good max drawdown looks like.