The pain ratio measures your annual return divided by the pain index, which is the average drawdown across your whole equity curve. A pain ratio above 1.0 is acceptable, above 2.0 is good, and above 3.0 is excellent. It tells you how much return you earn for each unit of time-weighted drawdown you endure.
What Is the Pain Ratio?
The pain ratio is a risk-adjusted return metric built on the pain index. The pain index is the mean of all drawdown values measured at every point in time, so it captures both how deep and how long your drawdowns were. The pain ratio then asks whether your return justified that pain. It is a close cousin of the Ulcer index, but it uses a simple average instead of squaring the drawdowns.
Pain index = average of all drawdown percentages across the period. Pain ratio = annualised return / pain index (risk-free rate is sometimes subtracted from the return).
Pain Ratio Formula and Worked Example
- 1Build your equity curve with one data point per day (or per trade).
- 2At each point, calculate the drawdown from the most recent equity high. Use 0% when equity is at a new high.
- 3Average all those drawdown values. This is your pain index.
- 4Calculate your annualised return over the same period.
- 5Divide the annualised return by the pain index.
Example: you earn an annualised return of 20%. Across 250 trading days, your average drawdown from the running peak is 5%, so your pain index is 5. Pain ratio = 20 / 5 = 4.0. Now suppose a second trader also earns 20% but spends months deep underwater, giving a pain index of 12. Their pain ratio is 1.67. The same return, a very different experience.
Pain Ratio Benchmarks
| Pain ratio | Rating | What it usually means |
|---|---|---|
| Below 0.5 | Weak | Time spent underwater outweighs the return |
| 0.5 to 1.0 | Acceptable | Adequate, but recovery is slow |
| 1.0 to 2.0 | Good | Solid return for the drawdowns endured |
| 2.0 to 3.0 | Strong | Shallow, short drawdowns and steady gains |
| Above 3.0 | Excellent | Rare. Check the sample size before trusting it |
> 1.0
Minimum target for most traders
250+
Daily data points for a reliable annual reading
2 inputs
Return and average drawdown, nothing more
Pain Ratio vs Ulcer Index, Calmar and Sterling
| Metric | Drawdown measure used | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Pain ratio | Average of all drawdowns (pain index) | Rewarding shallow, short drawdowns |
| [Martin ratio](/blog/what-is-a-good-martin-ratio-in-trading-benchmarks-and-how-to-improve-it) | Ulcer index (squared drawdowns) | Punishing deep drawdowns harder |
| [Calmar](/blog/calmar-ratio-trading-explained-return-vs-drawdown) | Single worst drawdown | Stress-testing worst-case pain |
| [Sterling](/blog/sterling-ratio-trading-explained-formula-benchmarks) | Average yearly max drawdown + 10% | Smoothing out one bad year |
Why the Pain Ratio Matters
Max drawdown only records the single worst moment. The pain ratio reflects the whole journey. A strategy that dips 15% once and recovers quickly feels very different from one that sits 8% underwater for most of the year, even if the second has a smaller max drawdown. Because it includes drawdown duration implicitly, it flags the slow grinds that erode discipline.
How to Improve Your Pain Ratio
- 1Cut losses faster. Smaller losers keep every drawdown shallow. See how to set a stop loss.
- 2Enforce a daily loss limit so one bad day cannot start a long slide.
- 3Reduce risk per trade after a loss streak. Review surviving losing streaks.
- 4Remove negative-expectancy setups using your journal data.
- 5Lower costs from commissions and slippage, which quietly extend every drawdown.
- 6Limit correlated positions. See portfolio heat.
Limitations
- It needs frequent data points. Trade-by-trade curves and daily curves can give different answers.
- A simple average understates rare but severe drawdowns.
- Definitions vary: some platforms subtract the risk-free rate, others do not.
- Small samples can mislead. See how many trades you need.
Returns pay the bills, but time underwater is what you actually feel. The pain ratio puts a number on it.
TradeEdge builds your equity curve and drawdown history from imported trades, so you can track how deep and how long each drawdown ran and compute your pain ratio without a spreadsheet.