A good expectancy in trading is +0.2R or more per trade after commissions and slippage. Anything from +0.3R to +0.5R is excellent, and a sustained expectancy above +0.5R is rare. In plain terms, a trader with +0.25R expectancy earns a quarter of their risk on the average trade, win or lose.
What Expectancy Measures
Expectancy is the average amount you can expect to make per trade over a large sample. Measured in R-multiples, where 1R equals your initial risk, it lets you compare strategies and account sizes on the same scale. For the full derivation, read our guide on trading expectancy and on R-multiples.
Expectancy (R) = (win rate x average win in R) - (loss rate x average loss in R). A positive number means the system has an edge. A negative number means it loses over time.
Expectancy Benchmarks
| Expectancy per trade | Rating | What it usually means |
|---|---|---|
| Below 0R | Losing | No edge, or an edge eaten by costs. Do not scale up. |
| 0R to +0.1R | Marginal | Costs and a few bad trades can wipe it out. |
| +0.1R to +0.2R | Acceptable | Thin edge. Works only with strict discipline and low costs. |
| +0.2R to +0.3R | Good | A solid, tradeable edge for most day and swing traders. |
| +0.3R to +0.5R | Excellent | Strong edge. Confirm it with a large sample. |
| Above +0.5R | Verify the data | Rare. Often a small sample, missing costs or curve-fitting. |
Worked Examples at Different Win Rates
The same expectancy can come from very different profiles. Here are five systems that all produce a positive edge.
| Win rate | Average win | Average loss | Expectancy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60% | 1R | 1R | +0.20R |
| 50% | 1.5R | 1R | +0.25R |
| 45% | 2R | 1R | +0.35R |
| 40% | 2R | 1R | +0.20R |
| 35% | 3R | 1R | +0.40R |
Notice that a 35% win rate beats a 60% win rate once the average win is large enough. Compare your own figures with the good win rate benchmarks and the good risk-reward ratio benchmarks.
Why Costs Change the Answer
Expectancy must be calculated after commissions, spreads and slippage. If your gross expectancy is +0.15R and costs average 0.08R per trade, your real expectancy is +0.07R. Scalpers with small stops feel this the most, because costs are a larger share of 1R. See how fees eat into profits.
Expectancy Needs a Big Enough Sample
An expectancy figure from 20 trades is mostly noise. A +0.4R result can easily be luck at that size. Aim for at least 100 trades before trusting the number, and look at the range, not only the average. Our guide on how many trades you need for statistical significance explains the maths.
+0.2R
Good expectancy after costs
100+
Trades before trusting the figure
+0.5R
Rare level; verify the data
How to Improve Your Expectancy
- 1Cut the trades that break your rules. Tag them in your journal and compare their R with your rule-following trades.
- 2Find your best setup, session and instrument, then trade more of those and fewer of the rest.
- 3Reduce costs: trade liquid markets, use limit orders where it makes sense and avoid thin sessions.
- 4Improve exits. Use MAE and MFE analysis to see whether stops are too wide or targets too close.
- 5Review expectancy by setup every month, not just overall.
Overall expectancy hides the story. One setup at +0.6R and another at -0.3R can average out to a number that looks fine and teaches you nothing.
TradeEdge calculates expectancy in R and in dollars automatically, then breaks it down by setup, tag, session and day of the week, so you can see exactly where your edge lives.